It has been noted, more than once, that great creators are not necessarily the most compassionate or humane individuals the world has ever produced. Such is the case with Lydia Tar, the subject of the Oscar-courting biopic starring Cate Blanchett, called appropriately enough, “Tar.” Throughout the two hours and a half plus of running time, we see many instances of this, but it’s important to also keep in mind the saying that “Well-behaved women seldom make history.” Whether it’s possible or not to both achieve immortality through one’s creative powers and be remembered as a good person, the film is a fascinating exploration of a mercurial woman.
Beginning with an onstage in-person interview with the (real) Adam Gopnik, a New Yorker critic playing himself because apparently, he had the free time and inclination, Cate offers up a portrayal of a multi-talented musician who composes, conducts and has a degree in ethnomusicology, (which sounds like something Newt Scamander would major in), plus she designs and sews some of her outfits herself. Cate is the subject of a memoir entitled, “Tar on Tar,” and teaches at Juilliard where she has to explain to boneheaded millennials that the impact of a composer’s work should be measured by more than his or her skin shade and sexual orientation. Alas, she’s not exactly warm and supportive of those around her, including her long-suffering assistant (Noemie Merlant) or her partner (Nina Hoss) with whom she shares a home in Berlin and has a young daughter. The action moves quickly enough to Germany, where Cate is in charge of an orchestra about to put on a performance of a Mahler symphony. Cate offers up many insights about music, some in English, but also some in un-subtitled German because apparently the average movie reviewer (unlike me) is multilingual and doesn’t require them. She starts running into a heap of trouble, as her past actions return to haunt her just when things are looking rosy, as they tend to do in biopics.
Sadly, when Cate was younger, she had an affair with a musician who is now accusing her of sexual misconduct, and this is a scandal that won’t go away with a few simple denials. Although Cate can handle a mean girl who’s been bullying her daughter with a few well-placed threats, adult conflicts are harder to handle. Pretty much everything that can unravel does, including her personal life, and eventually rather than learning life lessons, Cate moves to an Asian country and experiences catharsis by swimming in a waterfall and getting a job leading a rather quirky orchestra, which isn’t explained well, it’s as if the director got a little bored and decided to just wrap things up already. But the film is worth seeing if you have an interest in classical music. At first, you will be aware that Cate is Giving A Performance, but then you’ll settle back and become absorbed in the movie. Cate slashes her arms about while conducting, she stalks around, she lies and betrays, she does it all. Watch for that Oscar nomination which is likely the point of “Tar.”